Unpaid claims are not lost money until the deadline passes. Recovery is mostly about finding them, sorting them and working the oldest first.
The six steps
- Pull everything that is unpaid. Start with the aging report from the billing system, including claims with no response at all.
- Sort by age and by reason. Age tells you urgency. Reason (the denial code, or "no response") tells you what to do.
- Check the deadline for each claim. Filing and appeal windows differ by payer. See below.
- Fix and resubmit, or appeal. A missing piece of information is a correction. A coverage or medical-necessity denial is usually an appeal with supporting documents.
- Follow up until the claim is paid or closed. Silence from a payer is not an answer.
- Find the cause. If the same denial repeats, fix it where it starts (eligibility, authorization, coding) so it stops coming back.
Deadlines decide what is worth working
These are the Medicare fee-for-service rules:
- Filing a claim: no later than the end of the period ending 1 calendar year after the date of service (42 CFR 424.44).
- Appealing a denial (redetermination): 120 days from receipt of the initial determination. The notice is presumed received 5 calendar days after its date, unless there is evidence otherwise.
- The contractor's decision: generally within 60 days of receiving the request, according to CMS.
Commercial payers and Medicaid plans set their own limits, usually in the provider contract. Each one has to be checked. We don't assume a limit that isn't written down.
This is why order matters. A claim that is close to its deadline gets worked before a newer, bigger one. And a claim denied with code 29 (the time limit for filing has expired) is far harder to recover than one that is still inside its window.
What recovery can and can't promise
Nobody can promise an amount in advance. Some claims were paid correctly, some are past their deadline, and some were never billable. A real review tells you how much is still recoverable, claim by claim, and says so plainly when a claim is not.
What to ask any billing company about recovery
- How do you decide which claims to work first?
- How do you track each payer's deadlines?
- Will I see every claim you worked and the result, not just a total?
- Do the payments go straight to my bank account?
Want to know what's unpaid in your practice?
Send us your unpaid claims list and we'll show you what's sitting there and why.
Request a claims review