A denied claim is money your practice already earned and has not been paid. Most of it can be worked, but only until the deadline passes.
How common are denials?
It depends on who is measured and how, so treat these as three separate data points, not one scale:
- 40% of providers say 10% or more of their claims are denied (Experian Health, State of Claims 2026, 204 staff surveyed in August 2026).
- 8% was the single-specialty aggregate rate for claims denied on first submission (MGMA DataDive 2023 Practice Operations data, reported by MGMA on March 6, 2024).
- 11.81% was the initial denial rate in 2024 (Kodiak Solutions proprietary data).
The number that matters is your own. Ask for your first-submission denial rate, by payer, for the last three months.
Why claims get denied
In the same Experian 2026 survey, the most cited reasons (share of respondents who put it in their top three) were:
- Services not covered: 53%
- Payer policy shifts: 31%
- Coding mistakes: 25%
- Trouble securing prior authorization: 25%
Some of these start at the front desk (eligibility, authorization), some in coding, and some at the payer. The fix depends on where the problem starts.
What the codes on your remittance mean
When a payer pays or denies a claim, the remittance advice (the ERA) explains the difference using Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARCs). These are maintained by X12. Here are six you will see often, with the official wording:
| Code | Official wording | First thing to check |
|---|---|---|
4 | The procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used. | Modifier on the claim line |
16 | Claim/service lacks information or has submission/billing error(s). | The remark code on the ERA that names the missing item |
18 | Exact duplicate claim/service. | Was the original already paid or still pending? |
29 | The time limit for filing has expired. | Proof of timely filing, and why it was late |
50 | These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a "medical necessity" by the payer. | Diagnosis and the payer's coverage policy |
197 | Precertification/authorization/notification/pre-treatment absent. | Was authorization required and obtained? |
The "first thing to check" column is our practical guide, not part of the code definition.
What to ask your biller
- What are my top five denial codes last month, and how many dollars is each worth?
- How many of those denials were corrected and resubmitted or appealed, and how many were then paid?
- Which payer denies the most?
- Do any denials carry code
29? If so, why were those claims late? - Is the same code coming back month after month? A repeating code means the cause is upstream and needs fixing, not just reworking.
A biller who can answer these quickly, with numbers, is watching your money. One who can't is not.
Want to know what's unpaid in your practice?
Send us your unpaid claims list and we'll show you what's sitting there and why.
Request a claims review